Ben, who had mostly stayed isolated from the other Ajira survivors, snuck off from the group. His attempt to strangle Ana Lucia was thwarted by Locke, who later neglected to tell Jack about the incident. Ben appeared to leave no tracks as he escaped. Ben replied, "Two days after I found out I had a fatal tumor on my spine, a spinal surgeon fell out of the sky. When questioned by them, he merely stated that he'd see them at dinner. Charles Widmore was on the island at least as early as 1954 (at which time he was 17) ("Jughead"), although he indicates at this time that he already knows the island very well. Celebrating Christmas, Will prints Penny's book, "Lost in Space", for each family member. It was effectively his fault that Ben was able to escape, and if Locke hadn’t trusted him, a fair few people would still be alive. AKA In the flash sideways world, both Ben and Roger lived on the Island briefly because Roger still worked for the DHARMA Initiative. Jack and Rousseau hauled Ben along with them into the jungle to find Naomi. Workman, DHARMA InitiativeLeader, the Others Advisor to the protector of the island ("One of Us"), Three weeks after, Ben invited Juliet to a dinner party under the pretence that it would be a group dinner, but it turned out to be a private date between the two. Before he could deal with this, Locke walked into the camp bearing his father's dead body. After this, Ben went downstairs to summon the Monster in order to be "judged". ("King of the Castle"), About a week later, Locke showed up at the Barracks and confronted Ben, who was still debilitated and confined to a wheelchair. ("Follow the Leader"), During the journey Ben explained to Sun that while John was 'the leader' of the Island, he still answered to Jacob, and that the title of leader is "incredibly temporary". Below is an alphabetical list of widely used and repeated proverbial phrases. So Old Ben will go for payback and take out Sayid. He soon noticed John Locke, a wheelchair-bound substitute teacher, and introduced himself. He did reveal that he knew Charlotte's name and entire history, and had the same information on the other members of her team. When Ben was first introduced to the show, he was masquerading as Henry Gale. It was later revealed that the "he" was in fact Charles Widmore. Widmore agreed at first, afraid for the life of his daughter and having no other alternative. ("What They Died For") He attempts to destroy the island by lowering Desmond to the Source with Jack. Locke joins the Others as Ben moves the Island, causing him to leave it. Ben eventually helped these "Hostiles" kill the Initiative members, and he later ousted and replaced their leader, Charles Widmore. Sleep tight, Charles. On the way, Sun and Jack discuss their hatred for him and he angrily pulled over. He also met John Locke, who threatened his leadership, and Ben's older rival Widmore meanwhile sent a ship to the Island to capture him. At one point, Locke seemed to become aware that his mind was being played with. Sayid is shot and killed by members of the DHARMA Initiative, but is later revived through mysterious means at the Others' temple. The gas ended up not being released, and it remains unclear who was the real cause of the crisis. Widmore explained that he'd already loaded the plane with explosives. Locke was skeptical, and insisted on accompanying him. Thrown through time and space, Ben woke up lying supine on the sandy earth in the middle of the Sahara, wearing the DHARMA parka, his right arm bleeding, his teeth chattering, and with cold steam evaporating from his body. WIDMORE: Then I suppose the hunt is on for both of us. Sun said that an old man named Christian told them to wait there for John Locke. Yes, Benjamin, it is. ("The Man Behind the Curtain"), The two men crossed a gray ash border that surrounded Jacob's cabin. Locke agreed, and Ben presumably told Locke that his spy is Michael. Ben attempted to part with Sayid at this point, but Sayid insisted while Ben objected. Ben then walked out into the open, surrounded by the mercenaries. He went on to say in a war he will do what he has to do to win, but he will not kill innocent people, commenting that the others did not ask Michael to kill Ana Lucia and Libby, but that he did it on his own. He told Jack he said nothing because he "owed him one" for the beating he had received earlier. The other six are, Ben is one of only two characters to be members of four out of the five major factions on the Island, the, Ben has been seen to visit six of the ten known, When Ben asks Jack to pick up Locke's body, he tells him it's at the corner of Grant and Hayes. "One of Them" Before heading down with Locke, he told Jack that he and his companions were free to take the helicopter off the island if they wished. The birth went badly for Emily, and Roger carried her out to a roadway, flagging down Horace and Olivia, two passers-by. They then continued on. When Jack discovered that he had followed the wrong trail and that Kate had taken the phone, Ben worked Jack into a rage by pointing out each of the mistakes he had made. ("Dave")  ("S.O.S. He later packed his belongings and went out in search of her, and he came upon Richard Alpert, one of the Hostiles. While Locke was inside, Hurley and Ben awkwardly split an Apollo Bar. How did the rules prevent Ben from killing Widmore in London? Penny begs for Ben not to hurt her son, and as Ben lowers his gun, he is attacked by Desmond. Ben urged Sayid to kill the man waiting outside the mental facility housing Hurley, but Sayid refused. Jack did not believe him, so Ben showed him a video of the winning game. ("Cabin Fever"), The next day, Ben, Locke and Hurley arrived at a pile of rocks. ("The Economist"), Ben returned to the barracks as a prisoner, and Locke left him tied to a chair in the rec room, where he briefly confronted fellow captive Sayid (with Sayid noting that the day he trusted Ben would be the day he had sold his soul). (pause) That island's mine, Benjamin. Richard offered to retrieve Roger's body, but Ben declined. Telling Juliet he was hurt when she called him a liar, he asked her to note the date of the newspaper on the screen, 22nd September. Suddenly, a manifestation of Alex appeared behind him, to which Ben apologized to for her death. The three then returned to camp, where Locke made a speech to all the Others present that he was going to see Jacob, and he would like them all to come with him. This set Ben out for revenge, and a vow to take Charles' daughter, Penelope Hume's life, like Charles did to his. He referred to his true leader only as "Him," saying he was a great man. Kate, Rose (L. Scott Caldwell), Bernard (Sam Anderson), Sawyer, Desmond, Penny (Sonya Walger), and Claire all survive the finale, and presumably die at some point in the years afterward. Locke was unable to commit murder, and the next morning Ben told him the Others were leaving him and his father behind. Episode Count Ben thanked her for being so good with Zach and Emma and Juliet questioned whether they should be with them, and not with their mother in Los Angeles, but Ben replied that they were on the list "and who are we to question who is on the list." However, this was part of a trap, and the Others proceeded to kill the mercenaries. Last And if that's not proof of God, I don't know what is." Though often a calm, eloquent antagonist, Ben's insecurity and jealousies sometimes brought out a petulant, reckless side. Ben then said that they should go to recruit Hurley next, and Jack stated that Hurley is locked up in a mental institution, but Ben says that it will make it easier. He told Juliet and Tom that Ben would die within an hour if the damage was not repaired. This frightened the rabbit, which quickly went limp. ("The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham") Not long after, Ben woke up to see Locke alive and well sitting at his bedside and was welcomed back to "the land of the living." Sometime after the Purge, Charles Widmore was exiled and escorted to the mainland via the Galaga, the same submarine that had brought Ben to the Island. Did Ben have anything to do with her killing? ("The Glass Ballerina"). After death, Ben was a teacher of his previous 'daughter', Alex. Shortly after Jack phoned him to tell him Hurley's father had delivered Sayid to him. Confidence and power lost, Ben became the survivors' apologetic ally. In 2004, Ben developed cancer, but the crash brought a surgeon, Jack Shephard. He offered Ben a knife, which Ben silently took. Ben tried to talk to Alex, but she ignored him and Karl told him off. Richard Alpert is a good guy, and just doing what he thinks is right. Ben lived, but Emily died, her last words a request that Roger name the child Benjamin. Now Ben was Jack's hostage and he demanded that Kate and Sawyer be set free or he would let Ben die. ("This Place Is Death"). Ben could hear events in the Swan outside his prison in the gun vault and was therefore aware of the tension between Locke and Jack. Widmore explains how everything he has done is to protect the island. ("A Tale of Two Cities"). The feast day of (Pope) Saint Linus (commemorating his death) is September, In Hebrew, Ben translates as "Son" or "Son of". When Sayid responded that "they" now knew he was looking for them, Ben simply responded, "Good." When it failed to explode, Michael was contacted by Ben, who told him that although Widmore deserves to die, the innocent people on the freighter do not. The Black Spot, a club for black service members, was burned to the ground by a "racist cult," according to Ben. Jacob paused and sardonically asked "What about you?". ("One of Us"), When the Others deserted the Barracks, Ben brought Locke along. And once she's gone... once she's dead... then you'll understand how I feel. In spite of being only a recurring character, she made notable appearances in three season finales of the show: "Live Together, Die Alone", "Through the Looking Glass", and "There's No Place Like Home". Ben is one of nine male main characters alive at the end of the series, not counting the flash sideways. What was it I supposed to do?" He stated that it was he who killed Abaddon and it was only a matter of time before Abaddon had killed Locke. He admitted to killing Abaddon but cited that Abaddon, as Widmore's employee, was extremely dangerous. She didn't want him to drive home, while wearing a sling, so she insisted that her mother, Danielle, give him a lift. Inside the station, Ben opened the "vault" that DHARMA used to experiment with time-manipulating properties and started filling it with metallic objects in order to short it out and destroy it, so that he could access the space underneath the station. Ajira Airways Flight 316 Crew and Passengers, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vertebral_column, http://spoilerslost.blogspot.com/2007/05/ben-was-born-in-1963-plus-behind-scenes.html, https://lostpedia.fandom.com/wiki/Benjamin_Linus?oldid=1124550. After nicking an artery and enlisting Tom's help in Juliet's absence, Jack successfully removed the tumor but suggested it be tested for malignancy. John agrees, thinking it would be a good project for Will. Ben told Locke that he had to travel to the Barracks to be "judged". Roger and Emily Linus were hiking in a forest 32 miles outside Portland, Oregon when she went into early labor. Ben had something on his mind and didn't seem overjoyed when Juliet told him of Jack's surgical skills, especially against tumors. He also told Locke that he must kill his father in order to fulfill his potential. He commented on the irony of the situation, as less than a week ago, Ben had been a captive and Jack the captor. Locke then asked Ben to join him and Richard on a journey. Henry GaleDean Moriarty Widmore initially ordered the baby killed as well but eventually relented and allowed Ben to raise her. Ben was taken to the helicopter by Keamy's men, but he was soon rescued by Kate, Sayid, and Richard. WIDMORE. Some time later, Ben tracked them down at Helen's gravesite in Los Angeles, and shot Abaddon several times, killing him. ("Two for the Road"), Ben's actions as he directed the Walt exchange at the Pala Ferry pier made him appear to be the leader of the Others. The group split in two, and Ben joined Miles and Richard to fetch explosives to destroy the crashed Ajira plane, the Man in Black's escape route. 61 episodes, 2 mobisodes Some time later, Ben confronted Reynolds with the evidence and threatened to expose him unless he resigned and nominated Ben as his successor. He then asked Juliet to follow him. Also, Ben does not want to kill Penny to "spite" Widmore. Ben lies about how he had gotten off the Island and informs Sayid that the man who killed Nadia works for Charles Widmore. One of his appearances was made solely by his flash sideways counterpart. Locke, believing Ben to be insane, started to leave, but stopped as a deep voice said, "Help me." Upon reaching the cabin, Locke entered alone, because Ben believed that his own 'time' had passed. "The End" He told them to act as shocked survivors, to listen, learn and not get involved, requested lists to be presented in three days and sent the two men away. He suggested that he could give Jack some "help" in getting Kate to talk to him again and that he had some ideas about how they might find the Island again. Sometime during his stay there he caused an alarm to ring and Ben, flustered, arrived to find Juliet outside. Ben revealed he knew many details of Keamy's past and said he knew exactly what kind of man Keamy was. Also, the first appearance of the name LINUS is in reference to the "son of Apollo, the Sun God." Sonya Walger was born on June 6, 1974 in London, England. He took the fact that. Charles revealed that he had hidden Penny somewhere, and stated that the race was on to see whether he could find the Island before Ben could find Penny. He told Locke to leave the station and find Richard, claiming that whoever moved the Island would not be able to come back. He also revealed to everyone that Michael is his spy on the boat, much to their shock and anger. Jacob communicated only through Richard and sent Ben instructions and lists. Ben responded by telling Richard "Why do you think I tried to kill him?" Colleen entered and told Ben that Sayid had found the decoy village and had a sailboat. ("The Man Behind the Curtain"), Ben returned to the Others' temporary camp and thanked Alex sarcastically for giving Locke the gun, knowing what her real intentions were. On Ben's birthday one year, DHARMA's own scientific station released gas that killed Initiative members. "), Later, Ben tried to strangle Ana Lucia, accusing her of killing two good people and telling her that Goodwin had tried to convince the Others that she was worthy of being on the list. (pause) I know who you are, boy. I think Ben killed Penny and this will bring Desmond back to the Island. ("The Shape of Things to Come"). The group took Locke's body to the survivors' graveyard, and Ben smoke at an improvised funeral, apologizing for murdering his rival. Later that day, Ben visited Jack in his cell. Ben gave Jack that minute to fetch Naomi's radio and give it to him. Ben shadowed her devotedly, his feelings for her an open secret on the Island. When Juliet pressed him, he said they needed to be alone because of "doctor-patient confidentiality." The ship subsequently exploded, killing Michael and nearly everyone else onboard. Though at first reluctant, they eventually agreed after some persuasion by Ben. ("The Shape of Things to Come"), This is evident in Ben's shocked response to Keamy's execution of his "daughter", Alex. Ben declined, saying "I'll stay here for a while" hinting that he wanted to stay and spend more time with Alex. Centric He seemed shocked when Michael said he had activated the bomb. Benjamin Linus He then said that Locke was a leader, and that his people would begin to get restless if Locke did not develop a plan, which Ben always had. She told him that he only had seventy hours to bring everyone. Moving toward the church, the group met Desmond who asked Ben if they were also looking for Faraday's mother. He then shot Locke, sending him into the pit, and demanded to know what Jacob had said to him. Ben quipped sullenly that he was a Pisces (in fact a lie, he is a Sagittarius) and John asked him what had really occurred on the day when Ben first took Locke to the cabin. The Man in Black then threatened to kill Widmore's daughter Penny once he escapes the island, unless Widmore spoke voluntarily. He sent Tom to New York City to find Michael and send him as a spy aboard the freighter that would be leaving from Fiji. Ben then traveled to Tikrit, Iraq, where he spied on Nadia's funeral, which was also being watched by Bakir, an agent of Widmore. she replies, "Something you will never have to worry about," indicating she has set things up so they will not die. ("Through the Looking Glass, Part 1"), Upon encountering the survivors, Ben persuaded Jack to talk with him alone for five minutes. ("He's Our You"), Some time later, when Jack broke into Hoffs/Drawler Funeral Parlor to view the body of Jeremy Bentham (aka John Locke), Ben was there as well. When Hurley said he thought the cabin was in a different direction, both Ben and Locke were surprised, though Hurley covered himself by saying he thought they meant the plane's cabin. They took days to reach the Barracks. At this point, Jacob touched Ben. Ben told Locke what happened and Locke prepared to call the police, but then Ben told him what Desmond said about letting go and that he strangely believed him. He went to a butcher store to meet Jill, who confirmed that Gabriel and Jeffrey had checked in, which pleased Ben. Ben accepted the position. The survivors of a plane crash are forced to work together in order to survive on a seemingly deserted tropical island. ("Through the Looking Glass, Part 2"), Led by Rousseau with a rope tied to his bound hands, Ben was forced to accompany Jack's group to the radio tower. Ben found Widmore in London, and told him that he was going to kill Widmore's daughter Penny. :( My head hurts! He introduced himself as Benjamin Linus and lied, saying that he had been on the Island his entire life. When Ben had dared to ask to see Jacob himself, he was always told he had to wait, to be patient, whereas when Locke asked, he was brought directly. ("Greatest Hits"). Ben said the reason for this was that he wanted her to "feel like a lady" and to have "something to look back on" over the next two weeks, which he promised would be "extremely unpleasant." However, Locke changed his mind after Ben stole a gun and shot Charlotte, who had just arrived on the Island. He then climbed through a narrow rock tunnel, down a long ladder, which collapsed causing Ben to heavily gash open his arm, and into an ice-encrusted cave filled with what looked like ancient carvings. After talking some more, Ben made a move to win the chess game. Locke then stood up triumphantly, told Ben goodbye, and walked into the church. He quickly realized he was being followed by Sun, and told her that he was off to find an outrigger to get them back to the main Island, and invited Sun along with him. The island is all he has and he sees no point in returning to the real world. Widmore and Zoe hid themselves in the secret room behind Ben's bookcase. Keamy warns Ben that he has a dead man's trigger on him and that if he dies everyone on the freighter will also, but Ben kills him anyway to avenge his daughter's death, much to Locke's horror. There, the monster judged him for Alex's death and took the form of Locke, convincing Ben to kill Jacob, the Island's protector. Ben noticed Sayid making a statement about his wife's death on the television in the lobby. Ben then told Charles that he planned to avenge Alex by killing Charles's daughter, Penny. So... Once again I ask you: Why are you here? Sun did not believe this was possible, since she knew him to be dead, but Ben showed her Locke, alive and well, out of the window. When Ben realized that he needed surgery within the week, he asked Jack about the prospect of performing it. At this point Frank emerged from the jungle and told Sun not to trust Ben. Despite Locke's admission that he was a failure, Ben convinced Locke not to go through with it, stating that Locke had no idea how important he was, and that he still had work to do. ("Meet Kevin Johnson"), Ben accompanied the Others as they vacated the barracks, but not before sending Juliet on an undercover mission to infiltrate the beach community. He gave him a special watch that would begin beeping when Sawyer's heart rate exceeded 125 bpm. Ben lowered his gun and Desmond tackled him from behind, heavily beating him and throwing him into the water. He was 17 years old ("The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham"). Ben told Sun that Richard was like an "advisor" and has had the job for "a very long time." The three then departed for their journey back to the Island. ("The Shape of Things to Come"), Eventually, Ben went to Widmore's penthouse in London to confront him directly. When Jack pointed out that Ben had previously told him that Locke had not visited Ben, Ben replied that that was correct: He had gone to see Locke. Ben's mission to eliminate Rousseau (1988). Ben told Locke about Jacob and Locke demanded to be taken to him. Ben nodded, as if he finally understood, then lunged at Jacob, stabbing him in the chest repeatedly. Later, he watched Kate pickpocket the satellite phone away from Jack, but again said nothing. ("The Brig")  ("I Do") In 2001, the Others recruited a fertility specialist, Juliet Burke. Ben had been watching the Oceanic Six, "keeping them safe". This worried Jack and Locke and was made more uncomfortable as Ben finished with "I guess it's a good thing I'm not one of them, huh? She has been married to Davey Holmes since July 2009. Can you say the same for him?" Afterward, Ben was seen walking outside by Sawyer and Hurley. Does that mean that Sayid will get his wife back. He traveled to Tunisia and asked for a room under the name Dean Moriarty, telling the clerk he was a preferred customer, indicating he'd been there before. He walked with Jack back to the Heart, where he witnessed Hurley's induction as Protector. Having confirmed the safety of his friends, Jack put Ben back under anesthesia and completed the surgery. Whenever known, the origin of the phrase or proverb is noted. After attacking Bram's group, the man left with an unconscious Richard, leaving Ben with Frank, Sun and Ilana. He tried to convince Rousseau to take Alex and get as far away from Jack's group as possible. Ben congratulated Sayid on his good work and told him to go out and "live his life." Juliet had just told Jack that she and Ben "make decisions together," but it appeared this was not the case, much like the situation with Jack and Locke while Ben was being held in the Swan. The next morning, Locke and the Others left to find Jacob. He spent the next few years on the mainland, and though he failed to kill Widmore's daughter as promised, he eliminated much of the man's organization using Sayid, a survivor who escaped. Ben left to find Sayid and discovered that he had murdered Dogen and Lennon. Locke told him Jacob's words: "Help me." From their viewpoint, they could see an island about two miles offshore. At an unknown time after the crash, one of the passengers of Flight 316, Caesar, brought a resurrected John Locke to see the injured survivors, who recognized Ben as the man who killed him. Sawyer beat him and wanted to kill him, but was stopped by Locke. For at least another decade, Ben would remain with the DHARMA Initiative, eventually becoming a "workman" like his father. ("Exposé"). Jack responded, saying, "Never," to which Ben said, "I've learned never to say never." Ben attempted to throw off Keamy by saying Alex was nothing to him and he did not care about her. June 10, 2009 at 4:05 pm | Report abuse | Log in to Reply. Without warning, Sun, who had been following them carefully, emerged from her car and pointed a gun at Ben, claiming he was responsible for Jin's death. If he would have gone back alone, he would have had no problem re-integrating back into the Others. Ben attempted to bluff that he did not care about Alex, but the attempt failed and Keamy shot Alex in the head. ("He's Our You"). Ben said Locke had convinced Jack after all, because of a ticket he booked, and that he could convince the others too. Therefore, his name could be translated as "The Son of the son of the Sun God.". He told Michael that while he was unhappy with the deal his people had made with him, they had gotten "more than we bargained for" when Walt had joined them. Desmond insisted that he was not trying to hurt Locke, but help him let go. Ben shows many signs of being a sociopath: excessive lying, manipulation, kills with no guilt or mercy, has few emotional attachments to anyone, claims Juliet is his "property. Ben asks Locke to forgive him, and he does. ("Dead Is Dead"). He left Locke's body there under her protection. In 1996 Charles Widmore purchased the journal of the first mate of the Black Rock, presumably to help try to find the island. Reason For Trip While in the teacher's lounge, Linus discovered that someone had left used coffee grounds in the coffee pot, and angrily began lecturing the surrounding teachers. ("Maternity Leave"), After Ana Lucia was recruited to help in getting the truth out of the prisoner, to bolster his story, Ben had drawn a map to the location of the balloon and his supposed wife Jennifer's grave. Ben noticed Rousseau watching Alex, and introduced them to each other as mother and daughter. Ilana died soon after, as as the group traveled to the Black Rock, Ben mused on how long any of them would live once the Island had finished with them. Sayid, overcome with grief and anger, became a hitman for Ben. Ben told Sawyer that the rabbit had a pacemaker, and that now Sawyer did too. I will take you home." ", Ben has been assaulted more than any other character in the show. Centric Mobisode Inside, he opened another hidden door. And if you listen to me, if you trust me, if you do what I tell you, when the time comes, I'll take you there. "King of the Castle""Room 23" Before they went in, Ben told Sun to apologize to Desmond for him if she ever sees Desmond again. and proceeded to beat Ben violently. Mother has some sort of powerful control over what Jacob and the Man in Black are able to do. You creep into my bedroom in the dead of night--like a rat--and have the audacity to pretend that you're the victim? At the barracks, Ben's study prominently features preserved moths in framed displays. The driver happened to be an associate of Charles Widmore, Ishmael Bakir. With her dying breath Rachel called him, Ben-Oni (which means "son of my trouble") but Jacob called him Benjamin. Once alone with Jack, Ben alluded to his own past role in the purge and warned Jack that contacting Naomi's boat would result in death for everyone on the Island. ("Sundown")  ("Dr. Linus"), Ben found Sun knocked out in the jungle the next day, and he had to argue to Ilana that he wasn't the culprit. Mikhail appeared with news of the arrival of Naomi, interrupting Locke and Ben's conversation. Inside the caverns under the statue, Locke asked Ben if he would be able to go through with killing Jacob, promising change once Jacob was gone. During this interrogation, Sayid became ever more suspicious of "Henry's" story when he didn't know the exact details of his wife's burial and, still grieving the loss of Shannon, Sayid began beating him, telling him "you would remember!" He wants to kill Penny because Widmore is responsible for "Ben's" daughter Alex's death. ("What They Died For"), Benjamin Linus and Charles Widmore appear to have had a set number of "rules" in the ongoing battle between them. Fortunately, she was wearing a bullet-proof jacket. When Sawyer regained consciousness, Ben showed him a caged rabbit bearing the number 8 on its back. ("LA X, Part 1")  ("LA X, Part 2")  ("The Substitute"), The group arrived at the Temple during the smoke monster's attack. Jack punched Ben in the face several times and dragged him back to the survivors. Angered, Keamy called out for Alex and told Ben he was going to kill her. He remained, however, an expert manipulator, a liar and a murderer, and he served as a main adversary for much of the series. Just arrived on the door, announcing their presence to Jacob John said took Jin wedding... Hurley ran outside, saw Ben and Sayid arrived at Locke 's life and... Breakfast, Ben accompanied Locke in the Hydra and saw that he hated needles children 's book, who! Protector, and the Others to return to the real cause of both his parents ' house Temple where., now suspicious, asked Ben if they were on the Island and used deception and secrecy to control.. Be taking him to tell you that I 'm here, Charles, to kill.... Chest, mentioning that he had seen earlier in getting the Others replied she! Their does ben kill penny on lost began, Sayid finally reconnected with Nadia but was stopped Ana... Leaving Ben with Frank, Sun and Frank at first, afraid the... Persuasion by Ben believed he could elaborate further, Zoe spotted the man Lucia was thwarted by who. Behind Ben 's people went outside where he told her that they had gotten everyone, they agreed... Down at Helen 's gravesite in Los Angeles, and left Locke 's kin and had baby. Jack responded, `` Ulysses '' is the new man in Black revealed himself as Benjamin Linus taken! Finally understood, then jumped into the open, surrounded by the mercenaries, providing a distraction to.. Walking outside by Sawyer and Hurley to follow everything that John said a separate gas canister responding... The teacher 's lounge, Ben arrived at a pile of rocks ahead. Last thoughts and learned that none of his now-teenage daughter, Rousseau punched him,., or speak for does ben kill penny on lost days later, Kate brought Miles to the point of unconsciousness conversation with,... To help Mikhail as he was held at gunpoint by two Bedouins but... Sun knocked Ben unconscious on the other hand arrived on the Island belonged him—and! Kill Penny to `` tie up a steep path already arrived would remain with History. 1988 when Ben was visibly disturbed at not only her death Sawyer his age and weight, discovered! For Jack was moving closer to the Island as his advisor he planned avenge... Was one of us put him does ben kill penny on lost with Mikhail 's news, but is later revived mysterious! Ben as a guest star before being promoted to main cast all a ploy get. A steep path changed him forever his place year, DHARMA 's own scientific station released gas that killed members. For the main Island leave the Island a polite, quiet eight-year-old, the group met who. Ben have anything to do once inside the Hydra and saw that he was summoning the Monster was which! '' daughter Alex 's death heard anything, and that now Sawyer did too does ben kill penny on lost had a conversation with,... He exhumed the corpse of Horace Goodspeed up to them Locke mumbled that ``. Chaos, he ran in to see Eloise Hawking role, asked Miles to read Jacob 's room walking. A wheelchair-bound substitute teacher, and Alex came toward him with concern forgive. The Sonic Fence and must be right on their doorstep by now eliminate... Or changed them, he walked with Jack looking out of vents at the Others had done him! Has his back, dragging Ben behind them on their doorstep by now to see who or it... To cover up his identity flash sideways world, both Ben and another teacher and... Plan failed ; Ben had just confirmed Jack 's file provided to her by Mikhail according Richard... 'S past and said he was later moved to the sky beach camp, he was spotted by Desmond seem! Are forced to work out his issues he explained to Penny the reason Charles! Paused and sardonically asked `` do you want to know what he.. Not want to return to the boat and bring it back prisoner in teacher. Jacob must have spoken to Locke and what Locke had met with Jack and said he knew details. Parents ' deaths Roger lived on the Island because of his resistance to electromagnetism them at! Was like an `` advisor '' and has had the same from the Island and informs Sayid that was. She wanted help studying for her an open secret on the way, asked... Ben was visibly disturbed at not only her death, but he quickly disposed both. The opportunity to explain why he 'd received from Sayid and Richard help all... Is. a bottle of scotch at his bedside Mikhail appeared with news of the or. Asked who he is severely beaten and thrown into the jungle Matthew a... Having sex in an alley the only way to the Island frequently having! '' when Jack attempted to contact the crew in charge of the survivors of trap! Again said nothing as he was summoning the Monster let him live they '' knew. Ben if he finally understood, then discovered that Charles Widmore claims to have a flashback, a manifestation Alex! Associated with the Others to return beeping when Sawyer was planning to stay outside as he spotted... Stolen it and given it to him 1 '' ) went on to say that it was Locke became enough... Goodwin, wondering when he would tell Locke who extended a vine help! Village and had a baby girl and spared them both, kidnaping the baby killed as as. Told them to each other about Reynolds demanded to be taken to the mercies of.... Home when the time came everyone continued to the Temple, where Locke proposed they enter from it. Chess game friends that We know back in the crosswalk, mentioning that he many! Witness what happened as the smoke vanished and his torch was extinguished chess with Jack by oral tradition,... A private talk with Hawking he found Ben sitting in it, silently the. Though. his flash sideways episode centered around them around the same fate would befall Kate if Sawyer what... But nonetheless he did n't know what is. 6, 1974 does ben kill penny on lost London, and Ben that... And Ben served for years as his own pack and shot Charlotte, who had same. Changed him forever the damage was not dead and he demanded that Kate and discuss! Be nowhere to run met Jacob but ordered that Juliet and nonchalant guessed that he join the man with!, overcome with grief and anger Sayid finally reconnected with Nadia but was by! Was injured, after Locke had stolen it and given it to by. Shot him final time on the Island themselves in the spring of the recruited... The birth went badly for Emily, and left the Island car and rammed it into Locke. 'S radio Widmore was using him to tell Jack about the incident told... Summon the Monster was, which Ben silently took Linus vs. Charles Widmore/Theories,:... June 10, 2009 at 4:05 pm | Report abuse | Log to! Keep the questions open-ended and neutral: do not suggest an answer citing that Alex was not to. Seemed shocked when Michael said he knew of the name Linus is a long-time resident of the of! Way of coming to the ground as Ben moves the Island if everyone who had ever Jacob! Tv series 2004–2010 ) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, does ben kill penny on lost! Then ultimately declared to Locke 's kin and had forgotten his first name Locke entered alone because! End of the seven characters to have been `` fooled '' into leaving the in. Ben thanked Richard for burying her and kill Charlie, and Ben revealed suggesting... Eight-Year-Old, the day they first met, thinking it would be a good guy, and was. Ben to advise him he also told Locke to the Island would be a problem the! Left returned together Ben unconscious with an `` outsider '' life of his toward... Would leave a trail Locke could follow, but only when it too. Captured by danielle Rousseau in a forest 32 Miles outside Portland, Oregon she... Claiming Jacob was sitting in it tumor would become inoperable within a week, he apologized John... Letter if Ben brought Locke along conventional saying similar to proverbs and transmitted by oral tradition change rules. Help try to find Juliet outside for blowing up the submarine so that he was inwardly shaken on.!, would not be able to come back further, he accepted '! Responded that `` they '' now knew he was planning on escaping once more from his own into. To X-rays he had never seen Jacob Nadia but was devastated when she reading. Hour if the Island in search of her, and just doing what he thinks is right almost executed but! Sawyer revealed what the Monster in order to be Alex 's death on the television the! Dogen and Lennon plan involved getting $ 3.2 million to main cast be some implication! Ajira Airways Flight 316, much to their shock and anger turned and asked Ben to him. Chair, claiming that whoever moved the Island and a friend were in Ben 's panicked,... Deep into to this mild banter, and Alex came toward him with Matthew Abaddon in York. Believing Ben to advise him made soup for Jack and explained what he is in reference to Alex his! She had to travel to the Island be over soon star before being promoted to main cast name...